I want to like her but the fact she has no major or interesting flaw (no, losing her mother and that serving as backstory for the player to cry for her is not a flaw) bores me. I dunno, it's like video games / anime always have that one female character they make completely useless or annoying, then they throw in that one female character who's stronger and cooler than all the boys for "rephrushion!!!11"
Plus her design is too similar to Peach which is unfortunate because I like her star motif.
On the good side I do like Captain Syrup but she's a Wario girl… yeah