>>318590[S2]
Okay, cool. So like you don't have a strong opinion either way in a moral context, but in a legal context, you think you should be allowed to murder the person who's hooked up to you, assuming you were forced into that position?
[S1]
Yeah, so in the moral context, so I'd have to think about it more. But in the moral context, if I imagine myself waking up, I can imagine myself waking up and I'm hooked up to you. And the question is, do I, you know, do I kill you?
Do I kill you? And would it be wrong rather? Would it be wrong if I were to kill you if someone else made you dependent on me?
I would probably have to think more about that. Regardless of what my view is morally, I think the case for legality is a clear symmetry breaker. Morally, it's still like part of me still, it would seem to be wrong for me to do that morally.
So I'd have to think about that more clearly. But I could take the view that either way though, I could understand if someone were to bring the argument that it would still be a symmetry breaker morally. Someone can say, okay, well, it's not morally wrong in the case of rape because you're not the person who forced this other being to be dependent on you in the first place.
Like I would accept that. I would understand that. There's no inconsistency.
Post too long. Click here to view the full text.